The Michaels Return Policy generally allows eligible merchandise to be returned within 60 days of purchase. Items normally must be new, unused, and in their original packaging. This guide covers U.S. purchases, including important differences between Michaels stores, direct online orders, and third-party sellers.
Before making a return, check the product category. Cricut products require unopened packaging and a receipt, while Glowforge machines and filters have a shorter deadline. Clearance merchandise, cut fabric, and opened trading cards have additional restrictions. Your payment method and whether Michaels can locate your receipt also affect your refund. Eligible direct online purchases can generally go back to a store, but Marketplace and MakerPlace orders follow separate seller return procedures. michaels.com
Michaels Return Policy at a Glance
| Policy Detail | Current Rule |
|---|---|
| Standard Return Window | Generally 60 days from purchase |
| Required Condition | New, unused, and in original packaging; defective merchandise has exceptions |
| Store Purchases | Return eligible items at a Michaels store |
| Direct Online Purchases | Generally return in store or initiate through online Order History |
| Store Purchases Returned Online | Not supported |
| Missing Receipt | Purchase lookup may help; unresolved receiptless returns require valid photo ID |
| Receiptless Refund Value | Lowest selling price within the previous 90 days |
| Receiptless Refund Form | Store Return Card and/or merchandise exchange |
| Online Exchanges | Return the item and place a new order |
| Major Exceptions | Cricut, Glowforge, clearance, cut fabric, opened trading cards, and gift cards |
| Third-Party Purchases | Seller-specific policies; no in-store returns |
The 90-day pricing lookback for receiptless refunds is not a 90-day return window. michaels.com
Understanding the Michaels Return Policy
For most eligible purchases, the deadline is 60 days from the purchase date, rather than the delivery date. Having a receipt helps establish the amount paid, but it does not remove category exclusions or condition requirements.
Before returning something, check:
- Whether Michaels or a third-party seller sold it.
- Whether a shorter deadline applies.
- Whether the item was purchased as clearance or another final-sale category.
- Whether its packaging and condition meet the applicable requirements.
Do not assume an unused product is automatically returnable. Cut fabric, for example, remains subject to its final-sale restriction. michaels.com
Return Windows and Product Exceptions
| Product or Service | Deadline or Restriction | Important Conditions |
|---|---|---|
| Most eligible merchandise | 60 days from purchase | New, unused, original packaging |
| Cricut products | Subject to the general window | Unopened packaging and receipt required |
| Glowforge machines and filters | 14 days from purchase | Receipt required; box sealed and unopened |
| Online-only costumes and accessory kits | Must be returned seven days before the holiday | Do not rely solely on the general window |
| Custom framing | Rework within 14 days of pickup | Return to the same store |
| Classes | Refundable up to the class start date | Check the applicable booking |
| Parties | Refund cancellation deadline is seven days before the party | No refunds within seven days |
| Clearance merchandise | Final sale | No refund or exchange |
| Cut fabric | Final sale | No return or exchange, except where legally required |
| Opened trading cards | Non-returnable | Opening makes them ineligible under the stated policy |
| Gift cards and prepaid cards | Generally non-returnable | Legal exceptions may apply |
Custom framing rework is a correction service, not a general promise of a cash refund. michaels.com
Cricut Returns
Cricut products require both unopened packaging and a receipt for returns or exchanges. An opened Cricut product does not qualify for an ordinary change-of-mind return.
For damaged or defective Cricut products during the manufacturer’s warranty period, Michaels directs customers to the manufacturer, except where a return is required by law. Keep the receipt for any warranty inquiry. michaels.com
Glowforge Returns
Glowforge machines and filters require a receipt and a sealed, unopened box, with returns limited to 14 days from purchase.
The listed Glowforge Pro, Glowforge Plus, and Glowforge Compact air filter models cannot be returned in stores. Contact Michaels Customer Care to initiate their return. For opened-box troubleshooting or damaged or defective equipment, Michaels directs customers to Glowforge support and specifies contacting that support within 14 days of purchase. michaels.com
Can You Return Opened or Used Items?
Michaels generally requires merchandise to be new, unused, and in its original packaging. Used supplies should not be treated as eligible simply because the purchase is recent.
Opening rules also depend on the product:
- Cricut: Packaging must remain unopened.
- Glowforge: The box must remain sealed and unopened.
- Trading cards: Opened cards cannot be returned.
- Defective merchandise: The general store policy recognizes condition exceptions, but manufacturer-specific procedures can still apply.
For a defective item, describe the problem when requesting help. Do not assume the ordinary unused-item rule or the general defective-item exception overrides a specific product restriction. michaels.com
How to Return an Item to Michaels
Returning an Item In Store
Bring the item in its required condition, along with your receipt or other available purchase documentation. Eligible store purchases can be returned at any Michaels location.
Eligible direct online purchases can also generally be returned in store. Bring the packing slip or confirmation email so the purchase can be identified. Check seller details first: Marketplace and MakerPlace merchandise cannot be returned to Michaels stores. michaels.com
Starting a Direct Online Return
For an eligible direct online order:
- Sign in to your Michaels account.
- Open Order History.
- Select View Details for the relevant order.
- Choose Return under Need Help?
- Select the items.
- Provide the return reason and condition, adding supporting notes or images if useful.
- Submit the request and follow the instructions supplied.
The system provides the next steps and information about refund timing. Use those order-specific instructions when preparing a mailed return.
If you checked out without an account, Michaels’ online help directs you to track the order, create an account, and then begin the return. Contact Customer Care if the order cannot be accessed. michaels.com
Can Store Purchases Be Returned Online?
No. Michaels states that in-store purchases cannot be returned online. Take an eligible store purchase to a Michaels location. michaels.com
Michaels Returns Without a Receipt
A missing paper receipt does not necessarily mean the purchase cannot be verified.
Michaels offers receipt lookup for purchases made with a credit or debit card. Its policy also describes lookup for online or store purchases associated with a Michaels Rewards number. When a receipt is located, the return follows the receipt-based process.
If Michaels cannot locate the receipt:
- You must present an accepted valid photo ID.
- ID information is recorded for refund authorization and fraud prevention.
- The refund uses the item’s lowest selling price within the previous 90 days.
- The refund is provided as a Store Return Card and/or merchandise exchange.
Accepted identification includes specified government-issued driver’s licenses and identification cards, passports, and U.S. military identification. Category restrictions still apply; Cricut and Glowforge explicitly require receipts. Michaels also reserves the right to limit returns and exchanges. michaels.com
Return Shipping Fees and Other Charges
Do not assume every return method is free. The applicable process depends on the seller and purchase type.
| Purchase Type | Shipping or Fee Information |
|---|---|
| Direct Michaels online order | Follow the instructions provided after submitting the return; the general policy does not state one universal return-label fee |
| Marketplace purchase | Return initiation provides a prepaid UPS label |
| MakerPlace purchase | Customer pays return shipping; seller approval and coordination apply |
| MichaelsPro purchase | Restocking fees may apply |
A prepaid label does not establish that every seller offers identical refund terms. Review the seller’s policy before sending merchandise. michaels.com
Are Original Shipping Charges Refunded?
Original shipping and handling charges may be excluded from the refund unless the return results from Michaels’ error. These charges are separate from the cost of shipping the item back.
If the wrong product arrived or there was another fulfillment problem, explain that when requesting the return so the reason is recorded correctly. michaels.com
Refund Methods and Processing Times
Michaels generally refunds the original payment method, with specific exceptions.
| Payment or Return Situation | Stated Refund Treatment |
|---|---|
| Standard eligible purchase | Original payment method, subject to exceptions |
| Debit-card purchase | Cash |
| Gift-card purchase | Store Return Card |
| Gift-receipt return | Store Return Card |
| Check purchase | A 10-day waiting period applies; within that period, a Return Card may be used |
| Online PayPal purchase returned in store | Cash up to $500; contact Customer Care for larger amounts |
| Accepted return without a located receipt | Store Return Card and/or merchandise exchange |
Applicable tax for the returned item is included in the refund. michaels.com
How Long Does a Refund Take?
The main U.S. return-policy page does not promise one processing time for every return. For online requests, Michaels provides refund-timing information after submission.
Keep these stages separate when following up:
- Shipping the merchandise back, if required.
- Michaels or the seller handling the return.
- The payment provider posting the refund.
Check the timing supplied for your request before assuming the refund is overdue.
Affirm Purchases
Michaels describes using the original Affirm virtual card through a phone’s digital wallet for a contactless return. If that virtual card is unavailable, its policy allows processing to another debit or credit card. Ask for assistance if neither option is available. michaels.com
Does Michaels Offer Exchanges?
Eligible store purchases may be exchanged, subject to the applicable conditions and exceptions.
For the direct online return process, Michaels instructs customers to return the product and place a new order instead of requesting a direct exchange.
These are separate channel rules. An in-store exchange provision does not establish that an online replacement can be processed through the same workflow. michaels.com
Marketplace and MakerPlace Returns
Third-party purchases follow the seller’s policy rather than automatically receiving the standard Michaels terms.
Marketplace Orders
Open Orders in your account and select Create a Return. Michaels states that a prepaid UPS shipping label is provided to send the merchandise directly to the Marketplace seller.
Check that seller’s return window and restrictions. Marketplace merchandise cannot be returned in store.
MakerPlace Orders
Start the request through Orders and Create Return. Once approved, the seller coordinates the return with you. The customer pays return shipping.
MakerPlace products are also ineligible for in-store returns. Contact the seller if the return terms or approval status are unclear. michaels.com
Damaged, Defective, or Incorrect Items
Report a problem promptly through the online return process or Customer Care. For an online request, select the accurate reason and condition, and use the available photo or video option when it helps show the issue.
Keep the packaging and purchase records while awaiting instructions. Ask whether the next action is a return, replacement request, or manufacturer-support claim.
Product-specific rules matter here. Cricut warranty problems are directed to the manufacturer, while Glowforge has its own support instructions. A warranty claim is separate from returning an unwanted, unopened item. michaels.com
Gift Returns, Sale Items, and Holiday Purchases
Gift-receipt returns and returns of purchases paid for with gift cards receive a Store Return Card. Returning an eligible item bought with a gift card is different from returning the gift card itself; gift cards and prepaid cards are generally non-returnable.
An ordinary sale discount should not be confused with clearance. Clearance purchases are final sale, with no refund or exchange under the stated policy.
The reviewed general policy does not publish a blanket holiday extension. Plan around the normal deadline and any category restrictions. Online-only costumes and accessory kits have a separate requirement: return them seven days before the holiday. michaels.com
Michaels Rewards and MichaelsPro Returns
Michaels Rewards can help with purchase lookup when the transaction is associated with your Rewards number. The general policy does not establish a longer return window merely for being a Rewards member.
MichaelsPro purchases have a stated 60-day window, require a Return Authorization, and may incur restocking fees. Contact the dedicated MichaelsPro support team before sending back an order. michaels.com
Late Returns and Return Denials
The published policy does not guarantee acceptance after the applicable deadline. Having no receipt is not a way to extend that deadline.
A return may fail to qualify because it is late, used, excluded, missing required packaging or documentation, or submitted through the wrong channel.
If your return is denied:
- Ask which requirement prevents acceptance.
- Check the receipt, seller, purchase date, and product category.
- Request purchase lookup if missing proof is the issue.
- Contact Customer Care with the relevant records.
- For a defective machine, check the applicable manufacturer-support process.
Do not assume a manager can override a product exclusion or expired window.
How to Contact Michaels and Track a Return
For general return assistance, call 1-800-MICHAELS (1-800-642-4235). Michaels also offers chat through Customer Care.
For MichaelsPro Return Authorization, call 1-833-MIKEPRO (1-833-645-3776). michaels.com
After initiating an online return, use View Return Details to review the request. Keep any shipping label, carrier tracking number, handoff receipt, and refund confirmation. If a refund does not arrive within the timing provided, have those records ready when contacting support.
Read Next
Explore more helpful guides from this category.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Many Days Do You Have to Return Something to Michaels?
Most eligible merchandise has a 60-day window from purchase. Some categories have shorter deadlines or are excluded entirely.
Can Michaels Look Up a Lost Receipt?
Yes. Michaels describes lookup using a credit or debit card and, for associated purchases, a Michaels Rewards number. If the receipt cannot be found, photo-ID and receiptless-refund conditions apply.
Can You Return Michaels Online Orders In Store?
Eligible direct online orders can generally be returned in store. Marketplace and MakerPlace orders cannot, and certain Glowforge models require Customer Care handling.
Can You Return an Opened Cricut Product?
The standard Cricut return rule requires unopened packaging and a receipt. Damaged or defective products during the manufacturer’s warranty period follow the manufacturer process, subject to applicable legal requirements.
Can You Return Clearance or Cut Fabric?
Clearance merchandise is final sale and cannot be refunded or exchanged. Cut fabric is also final sale, except where a return or exchange is required by law.
Are Michaels Returns Free?
There is no single published fee rule covering every purchase channel. Marketplace provides a prepaid UPS label, MakerPlace customers pay return shipping, and MichaelsPro restocking fees may apply.
Can You Exchange a Michaels Online Purchase?
The online process requires a return followed by a new order. Eligible store purchases have a separate exchange provision.
Does Michaels Have a 90-Day Return Policy?
The standard window is 60 days. The 90-day figure refers to the selling-price lookback used to value certain receiptless refunds. michaels.com
Conclusion
The Michaels Return Policy generally gives customers 60 days from purchase to return eligible new, unused merchandise in its original packaging. Check the category before opening or returning anything: Cricut requires unopened packaging and a receipt, Glowforge has a shorter deadline, and clearance and cut fabric have final-sale restrictions.
Confirm who sold an online item before visiting a store, because third-party orders follow seller procedures. Keep your purchase documentation, submit the request before the applicable deadline, and retain shipping or handoff records until the return and refund are complete.